| 10 Steps To Creating an Effective
WebQuest
by: Jordy Whitmer
These steps are intended to be used only as a guideline. WebQuest
design is rarely a linear process, more often recursive and sometimes
messy. The steps listed below are in the order they are most
often presented to students, not necessarily the same order you
will want to work on them. The WebQuest model was developed by
Bernie Dodge and others. Since it's inception it has continually
been tweaked, feel free to add or change elements as necessary
to best meet your students needs/interests.
1. Title: How can you catch the students' attention?
The title is your first chance to hook your students' interest.
Think carefully about the focus of the WebQuest and what
is likely to catch your students' attention. Try to find a title
that is both descriptive and creative. Alliteration puns, clichés,
shock, questions, and catch phrases are just a few of the
many tricks you might consider. You may want to write a tentative
title at first and revisit this section after completing the
rest of the WebQuest.
* If you have colleagues at grade or department level, brainstorming
titles can be fun and inspire adaptation and sharing.
2. Topic: What subject area(s) and topic does this
WebQuest focus on?
3. Keywords: Picking a topic is the easiest part. Unfortunately,
most of us cannot create a list of objectives or standards as
easily. Often, we aren't even quite sure of what exactly we want
our students to learn. One method of clarifying the possibilities
prior to deciding which standards they fit is to first list out
all the key concepts and skills we want the students to learn
related to our chosen topic. Most likely, you will then be faced
with the realization that, given the amount of time available
for the unit, students cannot reasonably be expected to learn
everything listed.
Therefore, you need to
establish your priorities. Wiggins and McTighe, in their book Understanding
by Design, offer a method for setting priorities. They suggest
using a graphic organizer that contains three nested circles (see
Figure 1). Take your list created earlier and divide the content
and skills into the three circles. The largest circle is for those
concepts and skills that are worth being familiar with. The middle
circle is for those concepts and skills that are important to know
and be able to do. Wiggins and McTighe state, "Student learning
is incomplete if the unit or course concluded without mastery of
these essentials." The central circle is for those concepts
and skills that are deemed "Enduring" or "Big Ideas."
These are the concepts and skills that students should remember
long after they have forgotten many of the details.
With the graphic organizer representing your priorities, make
a "best guess" as to how much of what is there can
be accomplished in the amount of time you have available. (You
will have to think a bit ahead to steps 6, 7 and 9 to consider
what task/processes and assessment will be required to achieve
these goals.)
4. Objectives: (including district/state standards)
- What do you want the students to know and be able to do at
the conclusion of this WebQuest?
Take the concepts and skills you end up with in the step above
and reword them into objectives. One of the best ways to express
this for yourself and for your students is in the form of a question.
However, many teachers are more comfortable with the more familiar
approach of writing behavioral objectives. According to Heidi
Hayes Jacobs, the 5 attributes of a well-formed objective are:
- The Subject - who is the learner;
- An action verb - denoting the behavior requested;
- A product - the observable outcome of the activity;
- The conditions - or stipulations for specific activity;
- The evaluative standard - the criteria for an acceptable
level of performance in terms of quality, quantity, or time.
Make sure that both content and technology-related objectives
are listed.
5. Introduction: How can you draw the students in even
deeper once you have gotten their attention with the WebQuest
title and prepare them for what is coming? Writing an introduction
is a lot like writing the first paragraph of a story or a report.
Your first goal is to make sure you have a strong lead. Depending
on how you created your title, it may serve as your lead. Similar
to the title, you want your first sentence to pique the students'
interest.
Many WebQuest designers follow their lead with an overview
of what the students will be studying followed by the essential
question(s) of the unit. Others prefer to start with a scenario
followed by their essential question(s) and then a description
of where the students will start. You will probably want to include
some elements of the Task.
However you organize your invitation, make sure to include
within it a personal connection for the students.
6. Task: What will the learner have done at the end
of the WebQuest?
"The task is the single most important part of a WebQuest.
It provides a goal and focus for student energies and it makes
concrete the curricular intentions of the designer. A well designed
task is doable and engaging, and elicits thinking in learners
that goes beyond rote comprehension."
Designing an effective task requires an understanding of the
many possible types of tasks and selecting the most appropriate
type (or elements from a couple types) for the curricular objectives.
Generally, the Task asks the students to create a product or
make a presentation of some sort.
Two sources of inspiration for designing an effective and
engaging Task are: 1) the Tasks others have described in their
WebQuests; and 2) Bernie Dodge's WebQuest Task Design Worksheet.
You may want to consider adding some elements typical of Problem
Based Learning. (See Problem-Based Learning resources listed
below in the Resources section.)
7. Process: What steps do the students need to take
in order to complete the Task?
The first stage in defining the process (steps) the students
will need to do in order to complete the task is to make a quick
list of the big steps. Then, try to break each of those big steps
into smaller steps. Sometimes, even those smaller steps need
to be broken down into even smaller steps. You know you are done
with this stage when you feel ALL over your students could complete
the WebQuest without asking you (the teacher) for help.
The next stage requires you to decide how much detail to give
them from the list of steps generated above. Obviously you want
to give them enough detail so they can be successful, but not
so much detail that they are merely following directions. Unfortunately,
that is never as easy as it sounds. By providing different roles
or perspectives for the students, it is possible to provide for
differentiation among those students who require more assistance
and those that are more independent. Certain roles/perspectives
can be described in more or less detail and the students can
be assigned or guided to select the roles most appropriate to
their ability.
There are many different ways to orchestrate the learners.
Typically, the students work in pairs or teams. The group members
should be mutually dependent. Often, students are assigned roles
based on jobs or responsibilities, though the roles also can
be based on conflicting perspectives. At times, you may not want
to pre-assign roles and have one of the first steps be to have
the groups divide the work as needed.
Make sure that your process provides steps for pairs/groups
to synthesize their individual learning.
8. Information Sources: What resources will be needed
by the students during the WebQuest?
Review the task/processes and assessment methods. List the
resources needed for each sub-task/role/perspective. Consider
using as wide a variety of computer-related and traditional resources
(books, periodicals, interviews, videos, etc.) as are appropriate
to reinforce concepts taught for all students (keep in mind differentiation
based on ability and media preferences). The more specific the
resources the more the learners can focus their attention on
the topic rather than surfing aimlessly (though one of your technology-related
objectives may be to search the web.)
9. Evaluation: How will you gather evidence that your
students have understood the concepts you wanted them to learn
and that they are able to do what you wanted them to be able
to do?
The completion of the task is not enough. Both formative and
summative evaluation are important. (A simplistic definition
for formative evaluation is: evaluation that occurs during the
WebQuest which is designed to help students and teachers determine
how they are progressing for the purpose of improving student
learning. Summative evaluation is: evaluation given at the end
of the WebQuest which is designed to assess students final understanding.)
Plus, you need to provide opportunities to assess process and
product through multiple means.
Examine your list of objectives and brainstorm possible assessments.
Besides the standard tests and quizzes, consider some of the
following evaluation methods: informal observations/discussions,
one minute questions, portfolios, peer review, one sentence summaries,
student generated quiz questions, journals, student performances
(speeches, plays, radio shows, debates, etc), graphic organizers,
socratic seminars, experiments, interviews, conferences, electronic
slide shows, models, museum exhibits, role playing, etc. Some
of these may be the Task itself.
Determine which of the brainstormed methods seem the most
promising and how much time they are likely to require. As with
the objectives, make a "best guess" as to how many
of these methods you have time to include. Make sure you have
selected some informal and formal methods as well as ones that
assess process and product.
For the selected evaluation methods, ask yourself, "What
should count as evidence of in-depth understanding as opposed
to superficial, incomplete, or naïve understanding?"
Clarify student expectations for activities/evaluation. Consider
creating a model assignment, rubric or a scoring chart. This
will aid the students in knowing to what quality they have to
do the task and it will aid you in grading the students.
10. Conclusion: How will you provide a sense of closure?
Will the students have opportunities to summarize and reflect
back on the experience? Will students extend or generalize their
new understanding to other topics/problems?
Just having the students "present" their culminating project
for a WebQuest is often not enough. Many students don't take the
time to compare their work with other's, synthesize what others
have learned and shared with their own understanding, or apply their
new learning to other areas. Consider what activites you could design
that would push the students' thinking in these areas. (Presentations,
group/class discussions, concept mapping with Inspiration, big questions,
graphic organizers, etc.)
For an alternate take on creating WebQuests, visit: http://webquest.sdsu.edu/roadmap/index.htm |